Monday, January 21, 2019

The Risk of Sexual Assault as a Disabled Woman


 Since this blog is called voicing vulnerability, I figured it’s about time I shed light on one of the aspects of having a disability that makes me feel most vulnerable.

Like many of my feminine-presenting friends, I learned as a teen to walk home with my keys between my knuckles. We walked in packs when we could. We developed strategies for staying safe when we travelled alone. I’ve heard all the advice – be vigilant, observe your surroundings, cross the street or enter a building if you’re suspicious.

Unfortunately for me as a woman with low vision, much of this advice depends on eyesight. So, I’ve sought other means of protecting myself, including walking with a look of fierce determination, talking on the phone, carrying pepper spray, and keenly observing as best I can for anything suspicious.

Sexual assault against women is pervasive and tragic. Disabled women are even more at risk, with estimates indicating women with disabilities are three times more likely to be sexually assaulted. In their piece investigating sexual assault in women with intellectual disabilities, NPR found that women with intellectual disabilities are more than seven times more likely to be assaulted than those without disabilities. According to Disability Justice, 83% of women with disabilities will be sexually assaulted in their lifetime, yet only 3% of sexual abuse involving women with intellectual disabilities is reported.

The high rates of sexual assault against women with disabilities may come as a surprise, given the pervasive social tendency to desexualize disability. People with disabilities are portrayed as unattractive, undesirable, and broken. Yet, women with disabilities are especially vulnerable to sexual assault. This seems to be in part due to lacking senses or abilities that could protect against these assaults. Increased rates of sexual assault against women may also be based on the view that women with disabilities are weak and incapable of protest. It’s assumed that we won’t speak out against the injustice; and if we do, no one will listen anyway.

The risk of sexual assault makes me vulnerable. I am afraid when I travel alone. I'm afraid when unfamiliar people stop me on the street. I am afraid I will be taken advantage of because my disability makes me seem like an easy target. I am afraid I will be violently or sexually assaulted and won't be believed. I am afraid even if I am believed, I will not be able to hold a perpetrator accountable because I won't have detailed visual descriptions.

This fear is absolutely justified; being a woman with a disability objectively makes me more vulnerable. To quote Molly Burke’s Vice piece about dating while blind, “I have to be careful.” I am at greater risk of sexual assault and harassment and need to take additional precautions to protect myself as best I can. Despite my vigilance, I, like all too many of my friends with disabilities, have had multiple encounters with sexual assault. Within the past year alone I’ve had at least three public encounters, including inappropriate physical contact and verbal harassment, including being grabbed, screamed at, and followed. I don’t know whether these incidents would have occurred if I did not have low vision. Could I have noticed subtle signs of danger earlier? Would I have been able to escape sooner? Or, would they have felt entitled to treat me this way if I weren’t disabled? 

No woman, with or without sight, deserves unwanted sexual attention. It is never the victim’s fault for being the target of sexual assault. Nonetheless, we live in a society that makes us, as victims, question and blame ourselves. Systemic and structural inequalities silence women from reporting sexual assault, and all too often this silencing is amplified for women with marginalized identities, such as disability. I am so grateful for the momentum behind #MeToo, and I commend the bravery of the women who have shared their stories to expose the scope of this issue. And yet there is so much more nuance and complexity to the power structures that enable and dismiss sexual assault. Let's keep telling our stories and voicing our vulnerabilities. 

Wednesday, October 17, 2018

Celebrating Hulu's Accessibility Features and My Love of Audio Description


Most television- and movie-watchers have encountered closed captioning, subtitles that are included in TV programs to enable accessibility to those who are deaf or experience limited hearing. Fewer have heard of the equivalent feature for the blind: audio description.


Audio description is a separate audio track that narrates the key visual elements of video content, such as facial expressions, scene and setting changes, and on-screen action. Narration occurs between moments of dialogue to provide blind and low vision users a full media experience. You can find an example of audio description in this Frozen trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7j4_aP8dWA and can read more on audio description at www.acb.org/adp/.


For years, I’ve felt excluded from popular shows like Game of Thrones because the content is too visual. I can’t recognize the different characters and much of the action occurs without narration. I have spent an embarrassing number of hours “watching” movies and TV with friends or family despite being unable to see enough content to enjoy the experience. I attempted to emulate the energy in the room – gasping and laughing when appropriate – to hide my inability to share the experience. I felt ashamed that I couldn’t access one of the most ubiquitous forms of entertainment. I’ve since developed my voice to share when content is less accessible, however, I was still limited to content with sufficient narration and dialog or I had to ask someone to provide me audio descriptions or answer my many plot questions.

I first encountered audio description at a disability film festival. I hadn’t realized how much I was missing without the full visual experience. With audio described facial expression, on-screen action, signage and subtitles, I engaged with and appreciated the films so much more. Audio description gave me access to artistic elements that I didn’t even know existed. It had been so many years since I’d seen a film in its entirety: I hadn’t realized how easy it could be! Sighted readers may be raising an eyebrow; my guess is that you don’t often find it hard to watch TV and movies. For me, it’s often exhausting to try and remember features (e.g. “the brother is wearing blue, so if a blue blob comes on it’s likely him”) and piece together plot elements (e.g. “they went to a building – was it a school? A library? Which would make sense? Probably a school”). Audio description replaces my extensive mental gymnastics and enables me to independently and easily follow what is happening.

In April 2015, Netflix became the first mainstream service to incorporate audio description. Since then, I have wanted to write an “ode to audio description,” expressing my gratitude for the increased access afforded to the blind community by providing this option. In case you’re curious, most Netflix original content now includes this feature (though you can see a full list of audio-described content at netflix.com/browse/audio-description). To turn on audio description, choose subtitles and alternate audio.

And now, Hulu is joining in the efforts, thanks to advocacy by the American Council of the Blind and Bay State Council of the Blind. Hulu is incorporating screen reader technology and audio described content, which ensures that the blind community can independently use accessible Hulu content. Similar to Netflix, Hulu will offer an audio description feature alongside closed captioning that can be turned on or off. Hulu will also maintain a list of audio-described content to enable blind users to easily filter accessible content.

An important aspect of audio description is that it does not interfere with the viewing experience of those with sight. In fact, my fully-sighted fiancĂ© finds it valuable and shares that it’s especially convenient if he’s distracted. Similar to closed captioning, audio description can be turned on to enhance access to all without preventing access to others.  

While this is a giant step towards accessibility in streaming services, on the whole audio description remains rarely available and often flawed. Many movie theaters now offer audio description devices blind users can listen to during films, and yet EVERY time I’ve tried to use these devices there have been problems. Sometimes devices play the wrong movie’s audio description, other times devices play the correct movie, but the timing is wrong. Devices are regularly broken or run out of charge. Beyond the availability of audio description, how visual content is described has the potential to bias interpretations. Individual differences in interpretation, cultural bias, and more present challenges. For example, when watching To All the Boys I Loved Before (don’t judge me, it’s a great movie), I observed the audio-description did not read all text message exchanges. I was curious what was omitted and why, and how that content could have influenced my interpretations.

Despite these flaws, I am so grateful and excited that companies like Hulu and Netflix are taking steps to improve access to their content. Access to TV and movies offers promise beyond entertainment. Ensuring access to these cultural pillars sends the message that the blind community deserves equal access to participate in all aspects of society.